Over the past several weeks, we have spent considerable time reviewing the proposed 2027 budget, looking again at our financial projections, and considering the feedback and direction provided by council and the public since our first budget hearing.
I appreciate the questions and conversations that have been a part of this process. They have challenged us to take another look at our assumptions and consider where we can make changes.
As I submit my revised proposed 2027 budget, I want to begin by acknowledging one clear direction from City Council: we should not increase property taxes to meet our General Fund obligations.
This revised proposal reflects that direction. There is no proposed increase to the City’s real estate tax rate. Instead, we are proposing an adjustment to the City’s Earned Income Tax, from 1.10% to 1.30%.
Before I get into the details, I want to talk about what my administration is trying to accomplish with this budget. You’ve heard me talk about my priorities before: An Economy That Works, Government That Delivers, and A City Built for Everyone. And I know, these are lofty, aspirational goals. But they are meant to guide every decision we make. How can we foster a local economy that creates good-paying jobs for our residents? How can we provide the services our residents rely on and deserve as efficiently as possible? How can we make sure that everyone feels welcome in our city, regardless of their background?
We cannot do everything and this budget requires difficult choices. But these priorities should guide how we make them.
As we consider increasing our Earned Income Tax rate, we should be clear about what that means for our residents and what that means for our financial situation.
Our current revenue structure with EIT rates at 1.10% is not keeping pace with the cost of providing City services. While we have been generally on track to meet the projections we were provided with in late 2024, the economic landscape has changed (we’ll talk more about that shortly.) If we want to ensure that the city’s financial position is resilient into the future, we must consider adjusting this rate. This evening we will look at projections that demonstrate this fact.
What does this mean for an individual resident? Under the revised budget proposal, a City resident making $40,000 per year can expect to pay an additional $80 per year, or $6.67 per month.
This change allows us to generate an additional $3.46 million in revenue. That revenue would help us manage rising fixed and operational costs, address necessary changes to our Stormwater Management program, and provides a more stable base as the City moves forward.
But I want to be clear: avoiding a property tax increase does not mean avoiding difficult decisions. We have made additional reductions throughout the General Fund, resulting in approximately $1.25 million in net expenditure reductions from the original proposal. We have worked to preserve as many existing services as possible, but there are real impacts.
Changes that you will see reflect reducing proposed new positions, holding vacancies, and the elimination of currently filled positions. They also involve scaling back services that residents have asked us to provide or expand.
There has been a lot of discussion about looking at the things the City does that are valuable but not necessarily required. We should recognize that those things aren’t unimportant. Some of them make a real difference in our residents’ qualify of life, and how they experience their community.
One of these reductions is the investment in additional security for our public spaces, specifically eliminating my original proposal of a full year of Invictus Security in parks and public spaces. This is something that we’ve been asked to do more of, but we are limited in how much we can invest in a service that ultimately, we aren’t required to do, but many feel is nice to have.
This is why I believe that adjusting our Earned Income Tax rate now is so important. We need to ensure we have the appropriate recurring revenues to better meet our recurring costs.
Fixed costs remain the single largest driver of expenditure increases in this budget. These are expenses that we have limited ability to control in the short term, including pension obligations set by the state, healthcare and employee benefits, contractual salary increases, and debt service to maintain public infrastructure.
In 2027, these obligations are projected to increase by approximately $2.73 million.
These aren’t new programs or discretionary investments. They are the costs of maintaining our existing workforce, meeting contractual and legal obligations, and paying for investments the City has already made.
We can reduce travel and training budgets, defer certain purchases, eliminate positions, and reconsider programs. We have done all of those things in this revised proposal. But those adjustments alone cannot overcome the underlying growth in the cost of operating City government.
That is why we must look at both sides of the budget: how we spend money and how we generate the recurring revenue necessary to meet our obligations.
This adjustment is also informed, in part, by the Pennsylvania Supreme Court’s April 2026 decision in Borough of West Chester v. Pennsylvania State System of Higher Education, where the court’s ruling made it clear that services like trees and street cleaning are for the benefit of the community in general, and must be paid with General Fund dollars. And, we must remember that services like street cleaning are required under state and federal laws, and our EPA consent decree.
As a result, this budget moves those operational costs and staff into the General Fund. I want to emphasize that this is a funding allocation change, not a proposal to expand environmental services or increase stormwater fees. The General Fund is assuming responsibility for these costs, while the Stormwater Fund remains focused on the City’s stormwater management responsibilities.
I also want to emphasize that like the original proposal, this revised proposal does not include increases to rates or fees in any of our four enterprise funds. There are no proposed increases to Water, Sewer, Stormwater, or Solid Waste and Recycling rates.
We recognize that residents are already navigating rising costs in many areas of their household budgets. Despite increases in the cost of operating these systems, we have worked to avoid passing additional costs along to utility customers through this budget.
That is an important part of the overall approach we have taken: balancing our financial obligations while being mindful of the impact that City decisions have on residents.
Taken together, this revised proposal represents an effort to balance Council’s direction on property taxes while still maintaining the services our residents rely on, meeting our financial obligations, and being thoughtful about the long-term financial health of the City.
The revisions result in a net reduction of $1,255,356 in proposed General Fund expenditures. This reflects $1,445,006 in budget reductions, partially offset by $189,650 in additional appropriations that were omitted in the original proposal or have been updated with new projections based on new information we’ve received over the last month.
The largest reductions are within the Bureau of Police, followed by Neighborhood Engagement and Community Planning & Economic Development. The revisions primarily reflect staffing adjustments including the elimination of positions both vacant and currently filled, the elimination or reduction of certain services, and reductions to operating expenses.
The Executive Department’s proposed budget is reduced by $54,000, primarily through reductions to travel, training, and professional development expenses. This includes eliminating the Mayor’s travel allocation and reducing funding for Human Resources professional services, including the elimination of current training and professional development tools.
The Legislative Department’s budget is reduced by $10,000 through the elimination of proposed City Council travel and training allocations.
The Neighborhood Engagement budget is reduced by approximately $170,000. Adjustments include revisions to the Director’s salary, which will require the Mayor to continue serving as the acting director for a prolonged period. It also includes the elimination of existing personnel, reductions in overtime, and reductions to travel expenses.
The revised budget also eliminates the $25,000 allocation for part-time reception coverage at City Hall. This change is accompanied by a reduction in City Hall’s public operating hours.
You may notice that we have maintained funding for several Neighborhood Engagement initiatives, including our community events and civic engagement activities.
We have made a deliberate choice to preserve these investments. Our community events are widely enjoyed by residents and visitors, provide opportunities for connection, and contribute to economic activity for our local businesses. They are supported by sponsorships that help offset the City’s direct costs.
Similarly, our civic engagement work is supported in part by grant funding and existing commitments. Maintaining these activities allows us to honor those obligations and continue the work already underway.
That said, I recognize that the department has experienced significant changes in its staffing and resources. In 2027, I intend to take a closer look at the department’s organizational structure, responsibilities, and service delivery to ensure we are making the best use of the resources available to us.
The Administrative Services budget includes several reductions, particularly in Information Technology. Professional services are reduced by $100,000, and the proposed System Support position is eliminated. Additional reductions include travel, training, parking-related fringe expenses, and the elimination of the Pennsylvania Municipal League allocation.
These reductions are partially offset by two adjustments. The revised budget adds $150,000 for Community Involvement low-income assistance, which was inadvertently omitted from the original proposed budget. The insurance appropriation also increases by $35,650 to better reflect actual 2026 costs, as the 2026 budgeted amount was understated.
The Bureau of Police accounts for the largest share of the proposed budget reductions, with expenditures decreasing by almost $800,000.
The majority of these adjustments are related to staffing. The revised budget eliminates a Records Processor position, eliminates the proposed Administrative Assistant position, and holds certain Police vacancies at lower amounts to reflect hiring and promotional timelines.
The budget also reduces funding for the School Crossing Guard program by approximately $144,265. The City anticipates discontinuing its provision of these positions following the current school year, as it is no longer required to provide this service. The City is continuing discussions with the school district regarding other options for crossing guard services.
Additional reductions include a $30,529 decrease in the Police Cadet Training Program, which eliminates two planned positions and a $165,000 reduction in professional services, reflecting the elimination of the proposed full-year Invictus security contract for City parks and public spaces. Police travel expenses are also reduced by $10,000, which will limit training opportunities for our officers next year.
The CPED budget is reduced by approximately $155,000 on a net basis. The primary adjustments are the removal of the Economic Development Manager position, representing an $80,000 reduction, and the removal of the Permit Coordinator position within Building Codes, representing a $63,000 reduction. I want to be clear with Council that this will stall the progress we have made over the past year in streamlining our permitting functions.
Additional reductions are made to printing, travel, supplies, and professional services across Planning and Property Maintenance. The revised budget also adds $4,000 in Planning for training and professional development, which was inadvertently omitted in the original proposal.
The Public Works budget is reduced by approximately $84,000. Adjustments include reductions to Parks personnel expenses, eliminating a vacant position, travel, and advertising. The budget also reduces Parks Buildings capital outlay by $10,000, reducing funding for fixture and furniture repairs or replacements in parks and public buildings.
You will notice that Public Works has the smallest overall reduction outside of Executive and Legislative departments. That is intentional.
When making these difficult decisions, we have prioritized maintaining the services residents see and experience every day: clean and maintained streets, accessible and welcoming parks, recreational opportunities, and the upkeep of our public spaces.
These services are fundamental to quality of life in Lancaster. While we have made some reductions in this department, we have worked to protect its ability to continue delivering the services our residents expect.
Finally, I want to address the alternative scenario that Council asked the administration to evaluate: what would the budget look like if we limited tax revenue growth to less than 6%? This would mean adjusting the EIT to 1.23%, capping growth at 5.98%. This scenario would mean cutting an additional $1,630,050 from the General Fund budget.
The additional reductions required would be substantial. They would go well beyond the types of administrative and operational adjustments reflected in this revised proposal.
They would affect services and investments that residents value, including our pools and recreational programming. They would limit our ability to support community partners through grants and other funding opportunities. They would put initiatives like Vision Zero at risk and further constrain our ability to deliver basic municipal services effectively. They would also certainly require a reduction in workforce.
These are not hypothetical consequences that we can wish away. They represent real choices about what services our residents rely on that the City can afford to provide. Though not part of my revised budget, tonight’s presentations will include specific additional cuts for this scenario for informational purposes only.
Ultimately, Council must decide what level of service they want the City to provide our residents, what those services cost, and how we intend to pay for them. My revised proposal reflects what I believe is a responsible balance: honoring Council’s direction on property taxes, making difficult reductions where necessary, and maintaining the City’s ability to provide the services that make Lancaster a place where people want to live, work, and invest.
The City continues to take a proactive approach to managing its debt obligations while making necessary investments in critical infrastructure. In 2026, the City utilized data center building permit revenue to pay $4,061,000 in General Fund bond principal and $101,525 in interest, for a total payment of $4,162,525. This strategic debt reduction is expected to generate more than $400,000 in future interest savings over the remaining life of the bonds.
This approach demonstrates the City’s commitment to using new revenue sources strategically, reducing long-term financial obligations, and maintaining flexibility in the General Fund while continuing to invest in essential infrastructure. And, we anticipate debt service on our existing obligations will increase each year through 2029 before leveling off in 2030.
Finally, I want to be clear that this is not a normal budget year. Our revised budget reflects impacts beyond our control, such as stormwater management changes and rising fixed costs. We are not alone in this. Since our last hearing, other municipalities in Lancaster County and across the region have shared their 2027 budget proposals and are experiencing similar challenges. Our neighbors are facing multi-million dollar deficits for many of these same reasons. They are anticipating double-digit tax increases and will need to rely significantly on their reserves to close these budget gaps.
Ultimately, we’re in a better position than our neighbors. Thanks to revenue flexibility provided by the Home Rule Charter, and careful financial stewardship over the last decade, we can surmount these challenges. But I want to underscore that this does not exempt us, the Administration and Council, from having to continue to make difficult decisions in the future about how we generate revenue to pay for the quality services our residents require and deserve. But I believe this revised budget demonstrates how Lancaster does what it does best: we innovate, we adapt, and we work together to build An Economy That Works, Government That Delivers, and A City Built for Everyone.